Tag Archives: Elton Uliana

Who Wrote This English? Translation, Attribution, and the Limits of Literary Reviewing

We are no longer dealing only with the old problem of the invisible translator; sometimes the translator is perfectly visible. The name is on the cover, in the bibliographical information and beneath the title of the review; what disappears is something subtler: the translator’s relation to the qualities criticism then proceeds to judge. If a reviewer calls the English supple or funny, or admires its lyricism, who has produced those effects?

“Paper and ink, nothing more”: Saramago, Pontiero and Dürer’s Crucifixion

José Saramago spent much of his working life as a metalworker, a civil servant, and a jobbing translator before becoming, in his fifties, one of the most distinguished European novelists of the twentieth century. An atheist and a lifelong communist, he was awarded the Nobel Prize in 1998 for fiction the Swedish Academy characterized as “sustained by imagination, compassion and irony.” It could easily have been described as a long-standing argument with the institutions of church and state, both of which depend on specific forms of assent. Saramago’s increasingly open conflict with these institutions intensified, and eventually cost him dearly, with the controversy surrounding “O Evangelho Segundo Jesus Cristo” (1991), translated into English by Giovanni Pontiero as “The Gospel According to Jesus Christ,” a novel that retells the life of Jesus from conception to crucifixion.